I strongly prefer the soap. The creams are great too, but I find the ingredients in the soap to be superior. The soap lathers up beautifully and the post shave feel is unmatched. However, the scents of the creams tend to be more pronounced.
Cream Ingredients: Water; saponified stearic acid; glycerin; saponified tallow, palm oil, olive oil, and coconut oil; aloe vera extract; essential oil; kaolin clay; phenoxyethanol and caprylyl glycol; vitamin E
Soap Ingredients: Saponified tallow; water; saponified castor oil and shea butter; glycerin; saponified stearic acid, cocoa butter, and coconut oil; essential oil; saponified avocado oil, palm oil, and olive oil; aloe vera extract; kaolin clay; lanolin; vitamin E