I'll check this out. The No. 63 balm is my favorite post shave product. The bath soap is a bit odd; smells like Play-doh to me. Someone has a job where they signed off on that fragrance
I tried the EDT. It smells nothing like the shave soap. There is no tobacco scent whatosever. Its smell reminds me of Coppertone sunscreen. The drydown is much more of a thick creamy vanilla mixed with amber. It doesn't really work for me.
At least the scent doesn't seem to last long. When I sprayed my chest, neck, and wrists, the scent disappeared pretty immediately, thereafter. That said, when I sprayed it into my hair, I was able to catch whiffs of it throughout the day for at least 12 hours.