The only one I cared for was 3. It seemed like more of a colder weather scent. I got quite a bit of a dark, musky scent with a touch of, as weird as it sounds, dark chocolate.
I liked everyone one except the green one (I think it's #4). If I were to purchase one, it would probably be the orange one. I actually went into a Perfumania shop after work today (work at Columbia Sportswear in a mall) and asked the lady about them but she said she would not have it for a few weeks. I noted that she had a gift set of 4711 with cologne and some gel stuff. That's right, they sell 4711 in gift sets! But, to finish my story, the lady offered me a job citing how much I knew about scents! Go figure, when I have work, I can find other work, however when I need work, it seems hard to find.
I got #4 today, I looked at all four and I definitely liked #4 over the rest. It smelled pretty good in the store after walking around fora few minutes. We will see. Only problem is there are like three other flavors that I want!