I have Clubman Special Reserve and <3 it..a little goes a long way..and it lasts forever.
You might try Stetson Cooling Moisture. It's a low alcohol formulation, but has menthol (or something like menthol) added. It's a comfortable AS and has a nice cooling effect. The scent is the same as the cologne, if you've tried that before. It does't last long, but then neither does most aftershaves. I found it at a local Walmart.
B&B reviews for it:
http://badgerandblade.com/reviews/showproduct.php?product=203763
I didn't know that they still made this ... I thought it was discontinued
I think th OP is really Sir Mix-A-Lot.
"Clubman smells like butt I cannot lie
You other wet shavers can't deny
I used a huge amount not just an itty bitty taste
Now that fire is all over my face
I got burned
Smells like toddler cheeks
You guys that like it must be serious freaks
This stuff I won't be wearin'
For the scent I am not carin'
Oh, Clubman I wanted to like ya
So I thought I'd try ya
Other shavers tried to warn me
that mature scents just were not for me
I rubbed that stuff in my skin
I did not care for Clubman at all
At least it wasn't Lilac Vegetal..."
*drink all over monitor* Thanks,Top!