I'm a 2 month old wet shaver so still trying out new things. For my set-up I have a new Jagger shave mug that I use with Bigelow Shave Cream. It works great when I get my water to cream proportions right, but that's another story... Yesterday I found an early 1960's Old Spice Mug for $3 so bought it. Tried it this morning to compare with my Jagger mug. I found that the O.S. mug felt too shallow and the lather wanted to overflow. I think the O.S. mugs were actually made to have a soap puck in the bottom so maybe its not a fair comparison, but I'd say the Jagger mug is worth the money in comparison.