Yeah, definitely should have gone for Lime. This smells sickeningly sweet, like some sort of candy. I also have this Old Spice bottle that smells great, but it's practically pure alcohol. Looks fancy, though -- it's nice on my shelf. What are some quality aftershaves that smell good? I'm appreciative of this product, by the way -- it feels good on my skin, and it's going to last a while. But with the huge variety of options available, I might as well spring for the entire package next time. Reccomendations welcome.