Maybe you were using too much product?This is another one of those few products that everyone seems to like but do not work for me. And I am not fuzzy, I like most stuff But by using this balm I always felt sticky through the day even when using as little product possible. Sometimes I remember the stickiness could linger on even to the next day from the Nivea Sensitive. As it was the only stuff they sold were I live for a long time it was my only aftershave product between 2003-2011 do not remember what I used before that maybe another version of it. So I had a better than nothing approach towards it. Nivea Sensitive, "3 months old" Mach 3s and Gillette Black and Red foam was what I used (not in that order). It is strange because I like many of the other Nivea products not for shaving, Nivea Creme etc. Shower Soaps. Never have the sticky from those. But so glad for knowing about more options now.
IMO many shavers use too much aftershave. IME a little goes a long way. Less is more. Just a few drops on your hand, rub your hands together briefly to distribute, and then pat it onto the face instead of rubbing it in. Again, a little goes a long way, though I'm aware many disagree and say more is better.