Need your help: Lucky Tiger AS Tonic Vs. Thayers AB

[SydneyShaver]

Hey everyone,

recently finished up both my balm and splash and am looking to replace them.

For splash I've already decided to try proraso green splash.
The balm on the other hand remains a selection between Lucky Tiger Tonic and Thayers Aftershave balm. My thinking is that I use a face moisturiser after the shave anyway, so I only want something to help seal off the pores a bit, refresh, clean and soothe the face and maybe do a little bit of moisturising. I don't need something for its decadent hydration/moisturising and skin food properties. Both of these products get good reviews and cost almost the same where I am. So what are your thoughts on these products?

 

[Chef455]

I'll chime in with a vote for Lucky Tiger. I use it 5 shaves or so a week and love it.

 

[BigJ]

Another vote for Lucky Tiger! Great and very soothing juice, especially during the warm months!

 

[Wogus]

I do love me some Lucky Tiger, and I use it for pretty much the exact reasons you laid out.

That being said, I don't think the Thayer's ASB would be a bad choice.