These just arrived in the mail today and I thought I'd post some pics. They are 12EEE and barely worn. I grabbed these for $130 shipped...thought I did alright.
In my shopping experience, the Mctavish fit the same or just a hair smaller than some of the other Allen Edmonds models. In your case is the EEE is just a bit wide?? Or is it the length? What about wearing slightly thicker socks. Exact fit is best, but better a little loose than too tight.