Muhle or Edwin Jagger model 89 vs Above the Tie (ATT) M1 standard bar

[shawnsel]

Which razor head feels/behaves more aggressive to you?

• Muhle or Edwin Jagger model 89 razor heads
• Above the Tie (ATT) M1 standard bar razor head
• They feel equally aggressive to me
• I haven't used both razors
• I'm not sure

With what razor blade?
Please assume that each razor is used with an "average blade". The rational is that this poll will result in a summary something along the lines of: "usually the average Razor X is more (or equally) aggressive than/to the average Razor Y for the average shaver" ... so we probably need to avoid a ranking that is dependent upon one specific blade.

Can't see the poll?
If you are using Tapatalk or a similarly incompatible browser/reader, and you do not see the interactive poll above (with checkboxes), please feel free to reply to this thread with a one line comment like, "My Vote: Razor X is more aggressive to me".

Don't vote twice!
Please do NOT vote in both ways (reply and interactive checkboxes) on the same poll. However, if you accidentally do vote in both ways, please reply with an additional comment to help remind me to remove your comment-reply vote from the final manual tally.

Reminder:
Even if you already agree with the existing results ... please vote to increase our confidence in the poll!

Why this poll?
This poll is part of a series of polls towards averaging out the subjective experiences of numerous shavers, through model-by-model comparison polls, into a list of Currently-Manufactured DE Razors Ranked According to User-Polled Aggressiveness on a Scale of 1 to 10.

For details and a complete list of open polls, please see our Wiki page on this project at:
http://wiki.badgerandblade.com/Modern_Double-Edged_Safety_Razors_Ranked_by_Aggressiveness


Thank you for your time!


Cheers,
Shawnsel

 

[chris.hale]

ATT M1 easily, it's similar to my Weber.

 

[Aimless1]

If using the same handle with both heads the shave is nearly identical.

 

[alaskazimm]

I only have the M2 but it is most definitely more aggressive. It's also much smoother and gives me a much better shave. I never really cottoned to the EJ or got a really good shave from it.

 

[wagstaff]

M1, by a considerable margin, in my den.

 

[Jinx18]

I just voted that the Edwin Jagger is more aggressive after using my M1 a bunch of shaves. I can't believe people feel the ATT M1 is more aggressive. I guess it really is a YMMV thing because I even switched back to see and the EJ is definitely more aggressive. A noticeable difference.

 

[shawnsel]

This poll closes tomorrow!

 

[shawnsel]

Final results:
Muhle or Edwin Jagger model 89 has 4 votes
Above the Tie (ATT) M1 has 9 votes
Equally aggressive has 1 vote

Note: all comment-votes above are also listed as votes within the automated tally's graph


Conclusion:
The average ATT M1 (and from other polls, also the M2) razor head is more aggressive than the average EJ89 ... to the average shaver ... and (hopefully) with identical handles.


Thank you to all who voted!


Cheers,
Shawn