Money is no object . . . and you can have only 4

[MrMoJoe]

soaps or creams for use throughout the year. Using all of the criteria that is important to you, and choosing only from currently available product, which 4 would you buy?

 

[Batman]

MdC Fougere
Catie's Bubbles LVP
RR KOTC
RR Freedburg

 

[Silverirae]

I'm down to only 3 soaps. MWF, Cella, Proraso Red.

 

[canadiandude]

MWF
L'Occitane Cade
Trumpers Officer and Gentleman
Catie's Bubbles Purple Grapefruit

 

[wphelps]

MdC (Lavender)
Catie's Bubbles (Le Piment de la Vie)
Catie's Bubbles (Le Gardenia de L'Etalon)
Soap Commander (Passion)

 

[JimL911]

MWF
Tiki Fougere
Saponificio Varesino Felce Aromatica
TFS Bergamotto Neroli

 

[GreekGuy]

MdC Scented
MdC Fougere
Klar Seifen Classic
C&S No 88

 

[shep12]

MdC (scented)
Catie's Bubbles LPV (Ocean Grove is really close second)
Cella
Mike's Natural Pine & Cedarwood

 

[graysonhenryrussell]

MDC, Floris 89, Penn's, Harris.

 

[Vespasian]

TFS Bergamotto Neroli hard soap
Klar Kabinett (I know&#8230
Le Pere Lucien Rose de Pushkar
Geo. F.Trumper Rose puck

My Trumper is wonderful, but I've heard stories… Must try MdC.

 

[blzrfn]

C&S O&C in the aluminum jar
Pen's Blenheim Bouquet or Bayolea
Yardley (sealed with scent remaining, all mine have no scent)
Original Acqua di Parma shaving cream in the jar (croap)

Note that these aren't the best per se, but if I'm spending money that's not mine these all perform excellently and smell fantastic.

 

[sarimento1]

Creed GIT
Boellis Panama
Pens Bayolea and BB
is that four?

 

[entropy1049]

MdC Original Scent
Cella
RazoRock XXX
Proraso White

 

[MuffinMan]

MdC
CF Lime
ABC
Ursa Major

 

[BSAGuy]

MdC Fougere
Catie's Bubbles LVP
T&H 1805
Mike's Natural

 

[DrColossus11]

MdC - unscented
Valobra - unscented
Williams shave stick
Not sure about the last one

 

[gash]

Valobra menthol
Martin de Candre
Klar Kabinett (see here: http://badgerandblade.com/vb/showthread.php/428592-Klar-Kabinett-back-in-stock )
I Coloniali

 

[Steelman]

MDC Scented
Wickham's Super Smooth English Rose
Stone Cottage Cream Suede de Kashmir
CRSW Select American Barbershop

 

[bythbook]

Currently in production, hmm?
Just soaps?

MdC (original, scented)
Czech & Speake #88
Harris Marlborough
B&M Fougere Imperiale

creams:

CF Lime
AoS Lemon/Pens Blenheim Bouquet (tie - both lemony so only counts as one!)
Harris Arlington
Proraso

croaps:

Valobra Menthol
Haslinger Honey
Klar Kabinett (I defer to the wisdom of Gash, above)
RazoRock (the Xs, MF, &c)


gone but not forgotten:

Pens English Fern
Old Spice
Yardley English Lavender shave stick
Pens Blenheim Bouquet (original)
Acqua di Parma

 

[oldtrout]

Four soaps for me:
Barrister and Mann Lavanille
MdC (Fougere or Original)
Catie's Bubbles (Spice of Life or Ocean Grove)
Haslinger Schafmilch

AoS tallow-first lavender would be on the list if we are allowed to pick a no longer available product.
Stroppe Shop Special Edition double butter formula just missed the list, as did Mike's Hungarian lavender - fantastic products(yesterday or tomorrow, they may have been on my list).
I should have put a cream on my list...no, I never reach for a cream anymore.