I have been using Mama Bear's Spice Island shave soap for a week and the scent is great. (bought it via paypal at their website, shipping took about 4 days).
This soap does take a bit more effort at making a good lather. (to be fair, my previous was a TOBS cream). Their website as a demo video which is worth checking out. Overall, I am a satisfied customer.
I have the Woodland Pear, and it reminds me of the scent of Chapstick, in my opinion. Mama Bear's soaps are great, it's just a matter of finding the right scent.