Mama bear colognes

[drs]

Has anyone tried mama bear's dublin tweed
and/or her mountain water?,( mountain water may only come in a soap and not as a cologne, but it is still supposed to be her rendition of a creed scent). How do they stack up to the creed originals?

 

[thunder54]

Have not tried any that you mentioned but I have tried Ye Old Barber Shoppe cologne. It is really good. Scent lasts a long time on me. I hope this helped.

 

[bokaba]

Mama Bears are good, but I doubt her version of Green Irish Tweed is going to be the same as Creed's considering Mama Bear charges less than $20 and Creed charges $200.

 

[kingfisher]

Mama Bears are good, but I doubt her version of Green Irish Tweed is going to be the same as Creed's considering Mama Bear charges less than $20 and Creed charges $200.

In colognes especially, you cannot necessarily judge a fragrance based on its price.

 

[adonnellyr]

Has anyone actually tried both that can finally give us a comparison? I hear lots of hypothesizing on this subject, but never an "educated" opinion.

 

[bokaba]

Has anyone actually tried both that can finally give us a comparison? I hear lots of hypothesizing on this subject, but never an "educated" opinion.

I have both. MB Dublin Tweed is a nice aquatic scent, clean and fresh. GIT starts that way, but develops into a musk/ambergris base.

 

[adonnellyr]

I have both. MB Dublin Tweed is a nice aquatic scent, clean and fresh. GIT starts that way, but develops into a musk/ambergris base.

Are you comparing Creed EdT to MB soap or cologne?

 

[bokaba]

Both

Are you comparing Creed EdT to MB soap or cologne?

 

[Redig]

I was actually adding a bottle of Dublin Tweed to my cart when I thought to check if anyone on here had tried it. I have a little GIT here so I'll post my findings as well in a few days!

 

[Redig]

I have GIT on one arm right now and Dublin Tweed on the other, and there is a difference. GIT has a slightly different note to it, but I'm not convinced it's only the ambergris. I'm pretty sure if someone was wearing the Dublin Tweed I would at least think of GIT...it's a pretty good copy for $14.99.