MY was purposely capitalized because you might hate what I made, but it works absolutely perfectly for me. It's very simple and, comparatively, cheap to make. I used a recipe from Klopstick on the boards with a slight twist. It is 2.5 oz of Thayers medicated superhazel, 1 tbsp of vaseline intensive rescue moisture locking lotion, and a half tsp of jojoba oil. Mix well, put in container, shake before use, and enjoy. The witch hazel gives it the definite cooling feeling of an alcohol aftershave without the alcohol burn. It made my face feel the best it ever has after a shave and smells pretty darn good.
As always, YMMV.
As always, YMMV.