after reading the best of the most admired aftershaves,i have reached two conclusions...first,beyond any doubt ,superior 70 bay rum from puerto rico is the pennywise all time best buy...secondly...I must be one of the shavers on the forum with a few more years of shaving under my belt...(so to speak)..I vividly remember out here in california during the 50's and 60's all the local barber shops always had bay rum ,but also ,they always had SEA BREEZE for those who did not like the rum..this is my choice as the #2 all time best buy in aftershave...it is really great stuff..it does what an aftershave should do..close nicks, sooth and disinfect...that was the whole purpose of aftershave...the antiseptic properties....a GALLON of sea breeze on ebay is $25 plus shipping...even at $35 per gallon it's a real steal...it smells great..it lost popularity around the time barber shops started closing and pink walled "style centers" started opening up....too masculine a scent for some,not to mention when did you ever walk into a "style salon" and see vivid spicy centerfold photos on the walls ?? that was my absolute favorite memory as a kid going for a haircut (the magazine rack was # 2 !!)