What's new

Longevity (or lasting-power) of different colognes on me

Rudy Vey

Shaving baby skin and turkey necks
During the last weeks I have done some testing of the lasting power, or longevity, of some colognes on myself. I know that everyone has a different experience, but here are my results. The testing was done in a simple way, I just put a little spritz of the cologne I was wearing this day on my forearm and spread it out with a finger. During the day, I sniffed on my arm about every hour until I could not longer detect the scent. Purposely, I did not apply it to the back of my hands or on my pulse since I wash my hands very often due to me working in a lab a lot. I had my wife also sniff on me from time to time, on my cheeks or neck, where I normally apply my colognes.

Knize Ten over 13+ h
Creed Original Santal 8 h
Creed Tabarome Millisime 7 h
Creed Millisime Imperial 4 h
Creed Silver Mountain Water 8 h
Creed Vetiver (1948 formulation) 8 h
Creed Himalaya 10 h
Czech and Speake No. 88 5 h
C&S Oxford and Cambridge 2 h
G.F. Trumper’s Eucris 6 h
C&E Nomad 6 h
C&E Sandalwood 5 h
Elizabeth Arden Sandalwood 8 h
Castle Forbes Lonach 9 h

I will repeat this later this year, when the weather changes; I believe that temperature and humidity have also a lot to do with this, i.e. I sweat more in the hot weather we have right now. Some of the scents I wore two or three times before I settled on a time, a few I wore only once (C&E, E. Arden). But I will continue taking notes on all I keep in my den.
Some of these have a relatively short stay on me, like the C&S No. 88 - which is one of my favorites - or the C+S Ox/Cam which is practically gone within two hours from me. Others report these scents stay on them a very long time.
 
Nice post Rudy. Thanks for sharing your test results. I like the fact that you checked yourself, and got a second opinion from your spouse. Interesting that the Knize Ten has so much more staying power for you.
 
Now that's a *real* "scientific" approach! IMO, having a second (or more) party involved would be the only way to get any meaningful data.
 

Rudy Vey

Shaving baby skin and turkey necks
Now that's a *real* "scientific" approach! IMO, having a second (or more) party involved would be the only way to get any meaningful data.

You are right, but I have not too many in my household, its just my wife and I - my two dogs, though, have good sense of scent, but they report back not too well :biggrin:
 
This is a great post Rudy. I was doing some testing with 88 recently and have come to the conclusion that one spritz on my neck and one on my chest tends to last about 5 hours. It's not as long as I'd like (or, as you mentioned, as long as others have reported), but it's such a great smell that it makes 5 hours of longevity acceptable I suppose. Next I'm thinking of experimenting with some sort of unscented cream applied to where I spray to see if this gives it a little extra staying power by preventing the scent from drying out so quickly (I'm not particularly hopeful though).
 
I think, in general, colognes lasting *longer than I'd like* are more problematic than those that *disappear faster than I'd like*. I've found that my own impression of longevity/sillage is skewed enough to be irrelevant. I can guess, but the acclimation phenomenon make those impressions far off the mark.
 
Nice, Rudy -

I haven't tried the Creeds (samples await me) -

the K10 lasts & lasts on me - and the C&S 88 stays with me longer than your experience....

I hope you're gonna give some Penhaligon's scents a try - I find the Hammam & Blenheim Bouquets are up there with #88 (on me), English Fern also has pretty good staying power.




[unsolicited slam:]

Sadly, Pinaud Lilac Vegetal outlasts them all.


.
 
This is a great post Rudy. I was doing some testing with 88 recently and have come to the conclusion that one spritz on my neck and one on my chest tends to last about 5 hours. It's not as long as I'd like (or, as you mentioned, as long as others have reported), but it's such a great smell that it makes 5 hours of longevity acceptable I suppose. Next I'm thinking of experimenting with some sort of unscented cream applied to where I spray to see if this gives it a little extra staying power by preventing the scent from drying out so quickly (I'm not particularly hopeful though).


Place just a dab of oil on your wrists. Rub it in and then apply your fragrance. If you have particularly dry skin this may help. Any scentless oil will work, that is; if it will help at all. Wendy and I both had trouble with one vial of #88. The scent stayed around very briefly and was gone in under an hour. We both also tried using carrier oil unsuccessfully. The vial I just recently received does have staying power. Citrus fragrance is notorious for having a short time period of scent.
 
Well, here's a tale of a scent that lasts a long time.

Yesterday morning I put one spray of Endymion on my chest at about 7:15 am.

Last night at about 11 o'clock as my wife is hugging me, she says, "Mmmm, whatever you put on this morning smells really good."


Now THAT'S some staying power!
 
After many years of dabbling with men's scents, I find Creed's GIT and Odori's Tobacco last longest on me. Amouage Dia also hangs in pretty well (it ought to!) GIT is the king of long lasting for me.

But the question I've never resolved: is it the actual cologne that has longevity, or is it simply that certain colognes mix well with our chemisty and last longer as a result? I see many comments about C&S 88 being a long lasting scent, but I've test worn it twice and it dissapears on me in an hour or so. I recently sampled Aqua di Parma's Intense which is full of notes I like, but it doesn't even seem to make it to dry down on me!

I also must note that many scents actually last, but seem to become totally invisible to the wearer. I have a girlfriend who hates ANYTHING other than Issey Miyake. If I wear something else, hours and hours after I can smell it or even remember putting on a cologne, she'll remark how "horrible" it smells. I keep comments like kingfisher above in mind. Women have better noses I think. Just because I don't note it being there doesn't mean it isn't.
 
Last edited:

Rudy Vey

Shaving baby skin and turkey necks
After many years of dabbling with men's scents, I find Creed's GIT and Odori's Tobacco last longest on me. Amouage Dia also hangs in pretty well (it ought to!) GIT is the king of long lasting for me.

But the question I've never resolved: is it the actual cologne that has longevity, or is it simply that certain colognes mix well with our chemisty and last longer as a result? I see many comments about C&S 88 being a long lasting scent, but I've test worn it twice and it dissapears on me in an hour or so. I recently sampled Aqua di Parma's Intense which is full of notes I like, but it doesn't even seem to make it to dry down on me!

I also must note that many scents actually last, but seem to become totally invisible to the wearer. I have a girlfriend who hates ANYTHING other than Issey Miyake. If I wear something else, hours and hours after I can smell it or even remember putting on a cologne, she'll remark how "horrible" it smells. I keep comments like kingfisher above in mind. Women have better noses I think. Just because I don't note it being there doesn't mean it isn't.

I am a total believer that our body chemistry plays a huge role in this!!
The C&S No.88 you mentioned last for some guys a very long time and for others a very short time -seems that my longevity lays right in between.
The C&S O/C lasted only less than 2 hours on me, others report the whole day.
For example the other day I was wearing again my Creed Tabarome Millesime, and this time I could detect it very well after some 11 hours. Today its the Vetiver (1948 formulation) and I still can sniff it well, and I applied it also some 11+ hours ago. But I also must say that in the last days it is much cooler here, so the weather may also play a role (i.e. I sweat maybe less...).
I will definitely keep track of these scents and may add others as well in the future.
Another effect of our body chemistry is how a scent develops on us. Several have reported here that the find certain scents vile, while others rave about them.
 
.
For example the other day I was wearing again my Creed Tabarome Millesime, and this time I could detect it very well after some 11 hours. Today its the Vetiver (1948 formulation) and I still can sniff it well, and I applied it also some 11+ hours ago.

Jeesh...I have both of those in my collection.

I like your pens. May be in touch with you on those.

You ever try the "Vintage Tabarome?" The "flacon only" stuff?
 
Last edited:

Rudy Vey

Shaving baby skin and turkey necks
Jeesh...I have both of those in my collection.

I like your pens. May be in touch with on those.

You ever try the "Vintage Tabarome?" The "flacon only" stuff?

I never used any of the "Vintage" scents, they are just too big (8 oz and $$) - maybe a few guys could go in together and split one.....
Re. pens or brushes, contact me whenever you like:wink:
 
Great post Rudy, I was wondering about the same, but with aftershaves.

The lasting of the scent will have to do with weather and also the persons PH's I believe, since not all colognes smell the same on everyone.
Thanks for sharing.
 
Very cool post. I it always amazes me how different colognes can be in terms of longevity. From about 12 seconds for my T&H Limes to 3 days for an old bottle of Obsession I still have. (Ok, ok, so I'm exaggerating a bit....:biggrin:)
 

Rudy Vey

Shaving baby skin and turkey necks
Updated and added Floris Santal:

Floris Santal 12 h
Knize Ten over 13+ h
Creed Original Santal 8 h
Creed Tabarome Millisime 7 h/11 h
Creed Millisime Imperial 4 h
Creed Silver Mountain Water 8 h/11h
Creed Vetiver (1948 formulation) 8 h
Creed Himalaya 10 h
Czech and Speake No. 88 5 h
C&S Oxford and Cambridge 2 h
G.F. Trumper’s Eucris 6 h
C&E Nomad 6 h
C&E Sandalwood 5 h
Elizabeth Arden Sandalwood 8 h
Castle Forbes Lonach 9 h
 
Top Bottom