What's new

Llyn Idwal/Grecian/Charnley—A Outstanding Finisher-And Looks As Good As It Hones

A pretty large Charnley, 12x2.25x1.2 ish. It is extremely hard compared to my other Charnley posted (which is already hard) and makes an awful sound when you have to flatten it out - it took forever to get it flat, remove those scratches, and level out the back. Usually, I would sand off the sides and back before any pictures, but I just don't have the time for how hard it is. None of the lines cause issues, though it has a funky looking one on the left side I was originally worried about before having it in hand. It gives a lot of feedback (a bit more than my other one) with the middle dark part giving a little different feel than the outer lighter colored edges (I thought originally maybe oil residue, but I cannot get anything to come out, so maybe higher in abrasive levels). Puts a nice keen edge as the final stage with water only so far, though a bit scratchier looking under the loupe than my other Charnley - they both work well. I think my first one plays better with water dilution method so far, but time will tell with more testing.
 

Attachments

  • DSCF6529.jpg
    DSCF6529.jpg
    953.8 KB · Views: 16
  • DSCF6530.jpg
    DSCF6530.jpg
    863.2 KB · Views: 18
  • DSCF6531.jpg
    DSCF6531.jpg
    853.3 KB · Views: 16
  • DSCF6532.jpg
    DSCF6532.jpg
    743.4 KB · Views: 17
Last edited:
Another piece of the Penrhiw Hone flattened today. After the first one I thought there was a chance the quarry might have been the source for Grecian stones, but after this second piece I'm fairly certain it's not. Nonetheless the stones are extremely fast, coarse, and soft *for this kind of thing*.

Less consistent and a bit more flake-y this larger one, though to the touch you can't really feel it.

IMG-5075.jpg


IMG-5072.jpg
 
Last edited:

Legion

Staff member
Here is a bit of a group shot of my LI showing some of the range of apperences.

On the left are three novaculite LI, all looking rather different. The two on the right probably might have been called Idwal, for want of a better identification, but they are softer, and with a more slate like specific gravity. I'm still not sure how or if they might be related.

F1046F0C-042D-4E2A-AEC8-3E52588A1A35.jpeg
 

timwcic

"Look what I found"
I have seen many LI pictured over the years but not many this size. Cut as a barber hone, 2.75x5 inches and worn thin. Lost a mm or two lapping out some divots, found in the bottom of a box with tools on top at the flea market. Has typical slate-like cleavage on the bottom with a Novaculite hard surface. A good looker with nice saw marks

0C2F857A-2215-4BEC-8E04-63801C7FE9C6.jpeg
D00DCED5-1034-47CA-9980-EE0896F08D28.jpeg
00C074E2-4AFE-420E-9023-185259D7A4AB.jpeg
B5174451-D715-44A7-94E0-4885C59E14CD.jpeg
 
I have seen many LI pictured over the years but not many this size. Cut as a barber hone, 2.75x5 inches and worn thin. Lost a mm or two lapping out some divots, found in the bottom of a box with tools on top at the flea market. Has typical slate-like cleavage on the bottom with a Novaculite hard surface. A good looker with nice saw marks

View attachment 1635176View attachment 1635177View attachment 1635178View attachment 1635179
That also looks like it could be Vermont Green slate hone to me! Neat one!
 
Top Bottom