light box which do you perfer?

[nff]

ok made a light box (not the best but it works.) and was wondering which is better?

a:

or

B:

 

[BigBull]

A - to me it captures the subjects true characteristics. When I look at the kettle, in particular, the depth of the clay looks more real. In both pics, there is less defined shadow which to me is a good thing. You also don't see the glare off the bottom of the bowl as much...

Nice work either way.

 

[Blade Boy]

B seems to be a tad sharper.

 

[djh]

The first one diffuses your lighting; which is the purpose of a lightbox.

 

[nff]

yea A is difused with a sheet of tissue paper and B is un filtered.

 

[xillion]

I prefer the diffused light of A.

 

[Lamb Root]

I like the soft ones better, therefore 'a'

 

[Legion]

The first one diffuses your lighting; which is the purpose of a lightbox.

This

 

[nff]

and here is the results of a