So at an antiques shop last week, I picked up a little set they had... an Old Spice shaving mug (not the best of shape, the ribbon under the ship was faded away), a pretty nice Slim and an old puck of Williams all for $12.50. Tonight I decided to give the soap a try. Let me preface this by saying that I haven't tried either modern or vintage Williams so I was going in with very few expectations. All I knew is that there are a lot of modern Williams haters and that many say the vintage was much better. The only thing I was really thinking was that the box smelled super musty but thank goodness the soap just didn't smell at all. So I loaded this stuff up and whipped a really nice, rich lather. Boy did it lather easily! How did the shave go you ask? There was tons of cushion and even more glide. I'm seriously impressed by this stuff. Now I think I'm going to have to pick up a puck of the new stuff so I can compare. May have to order it though because I haven't seen it at any of the stores here. I'm also going to be adding vintage Williams to my antiques store list!