For me the canned lather works, not more, not less. Nevertheless, I stopped using it quite a while ago, as I didn’t like the amount of waste. I travel with a soap and a brush and face lather, which works well. I don’t miss the canned lather.
Is Haslinger the first true contender for Tabac?
- Thread starter Biltong & Boerewors
- Start date
I had a can that I had purchased before I started wet shaving. I decided to use it up and I had the same experience.
I wet my face, squirt some foam onto a damp brush, apply the lather and use the brush to work in more water just like face lathering.
Ahhh...epiphany! I’ll try that this weekend. I had it in my head that it was intended to be used without a brush for instant hassle free application.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- Thread starter
- #64
To be honest I never paid much attention to the ability of local water to generate lather, until now. I just assumed the water in Scotland to be fine as I never had issues with shampoo, body wash and shaving soaps.
In the past two weeks I went for a ten day family visit in South Africa. I packed my Feather AC and my tub of TOB, because I didn't want to pack valuable razors and strops and risk damage or things disappearing out of my checked luggage, as sometimes happens at Johannesburg Airport.
The first day there I bought Prep, it's a pre-shave cream that I used many years ago, and I decided to try it again. Wow! What a difference, The AC shaved better than I have ever experienced in Scotland, and I suspected it was the Prep that made the difference. Usually I get about four comfortable shaves from a Feather Professional blade, but at the end of my visit I had 9 shaves and it was still shaving fine.
Back in Scotland I tried the exact same method, and was sorely disappointed. The shave is just not anywhere near the same. The only variable is the water.
Can it be that softer water leads to better soap performance, but also allows the beard to be much softer resulting in a more comfortable shave and therefore is not so hard on the edge of the blade?
Can it also explain the fact that I find Prorasso ok, but not great, and you find it excellent?
I think it definitely makes a big difference.
I think water hardness can be huge. Here in metro Atlanta and southeast US in general, the water is very soft and I can easily get a lather.
I was born and raised in northeast Ohio and the water is fairly hard there. Folks there would buy water softeners for their bathrooms to provide a better shower. I was under the impression when I was a kid that soap suds developed more readily in soft water.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Curious not more Williams, Arko, cella comparisons, my other favorite tallow soaps! ( there a learning curve to the Williams).
The sandalwood Haslinger is vegan. I haven’t tried Haslinger yet, good to hear it/ vege soap holds up to tabac / tallow which is a favorite of mine.
I’ve had halinger’s in my saved for later basket for over a year, ran into a bunch of great soaps and haven’t ordered it yet.
The sandalwood Haslinger is vegan. I haven’t tried Haslinger yet, good to hear it/ vege soap holds up to tabac / tallow which is a favorite of mine.
I’ve had halinger’s in my saved for later basket for over a year, ran into a bunch of great soaps and haven’t ordered it yet.
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #67
I have been using only the Haslinger since the start of December. I didn't count exactly, but I am more than 60 shaves into the puck, and I would guess that there are at least 20+ shaves left in it.
I think using my normal face lather, two pass shaves I will eventually get between 80 and 100 shaves out of the puck that I initially thought was a sample.
That's great value for money for a top class shaving soap!
I used only the Haslinger for the last couple of months for a few reasons:
Performance-wise it is excellent, as good if not better than my favorite Tabac. Just about lathers itself, smooth slick creamy lather, stable, and good after shave feel.
However...... I really think it lacks in one of the important aspects.
The smell, or lack of it. I chose the sandalwood and initially there was somewhat of a fragrance, but that soon disappeared. After a few weeks I noticed a distinct ammonia smell coming from my lather. Thought my brush was the culprit because I didn't let it dry properly between shaves, but no, it was the soap. It was sort of the smell you get from a ripe cheese, which isn't bad, on cheese, but I don't want to shave with it. That came and went throughout the life of the puck and I can't really explain it.
Summary: Great performing soap, but lacks character. I can recommend it to anyone starting out because it is basically fool-proof. Would I buy it again? Maybe, but life is too short and there are many other soaps I would like to try first.
I think using my normal face lather, two pass shaves I will eventually get between 80 and 100 shaves out of the puck that I initially thought was a sample.
That's great value for money for a top class shaving soap!I used only the Haslinger for the last couple of months for a few reasons:
- Really wanted to test it with all my straights, shavettes and DE razors to compare it's performance.
- Wanted to form a firm opinion whether I like it or not.
- Wanted to know how long it will last.
- I don't want to accumulate vast quantities of soap, so I am going to use what I have before trying something different.
Performance-wise it is excellent, as good if not better than my favorite Tabac. Just about lathers itself, smooth slick creamy lather, stable, and good after shave feel.
However...... I really think it lacks in one of the important aspects.
The smell, or lack of it. I chose the sandalwood and initially there was somewhat of a fragrance, but that soon disappeared. After a few weeks I noticed a distinct ammonia smell coming from my lather. Thought my brush was the culprit because I didn't let it dry properly between shaves, but no, it was the soap. It was sort of the smell you get from a ripe cheese, which isn't bad, on cheese, but I don't want to shave with it. That came and went throughout the life of the puck and I can't really explain it.
Summary: Great performing soap, but lacks character. I can recommend it to anyone starting out because it is basically fool-proof. Would I buy it again? Maybe, but life is too short and there are many other soaps I would like to try first.
I found both to be exceptional and even like the Tabac scent. Unfortunately, after a year or so the Tabac started to cause my face to itch as did the AS and cologne. A real heartbreaker. I now use creams mostly but continue the occasional use of Haslimger Schafmilch and MWF.
The puck lasts “bigger” than it looks. You should give their Schafmilch a try. Scent is mild but quite lovely.I have been using only the Haslinger since the start of December. I didn't count exactly, but I am more than 60 shaves into the puck, and I would guess that there are at least 20+ shaves left in it.
I think using my normal face lather, two pass shaves I will eventually get between 80 and 100 shaves out of the puck that I initially thought was a sample.
I used only the Haslinger for the last couple of months for a few reasons:
Here is my personal opinion:
- Really wanted to test it with all my straights, shavettes and DE razors to compare it's performance.
- Wanted to form a firm opinion whether I like it or not.
- Wanted to know how long it will last.
- I don't want to accumulate vast quantities of soap, so I am going to use what I have before trying something different.
Performance-wise it is excellent, as good if not better than my favorite Tabac. Just about lathers itself, smooth slick creamy lather, stable, and good after shave feel.
However...... I really think it lacks in one of the important aspects.
The smell, or lack of it. I chose the sandalwood and initially there was somewhat of a fragrance, but that soon disappeared. After a few weeks I noticed a distinct ammonia smell coming from my lather. Thought my brush was the culprit because I didn't let it dry properly between shaves, but no, it was the soap. It was sort of the smell you get from a ripe cheese, which isn't bad, on cheese, but I don't want to shave with it. That came and went throughout the life of the puck and I can't really explain it.
Summary: Great performing soap, but lacks character. I can recommend it to anyone starting out because it is basically fool-proof. Would I buy it again? Maybe, but life is too short and there are many other soaps I would like to try first.
Price, scent and performance of Tabac is difficult if not impossible to beat.
I can barely smell my Tabac and definitely not Haslinger. My Schafsmilch is original with tallow, as well as Tabac. I hear Tabac has gone vegan, and Hasslinger did awhile ago. Not sure how I’ll like them.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Tabac
Slickness A-
Latherability B+
Post C
Overall - B
Haslinger
Slickness B+
Latherability A-
Post B
Overall - B+
Slickness A-
Latherability B+
Post C
Overall - B
Haslinger
Slickness B+
Latherability A-
Post B
Overall - B+
This one is very good compared
