I had some feather blades in my sample pack when I first started wet shaving. Having seen the reviews everywhere, I left these for months while I worked through the pack. Only recently opened the first feather. Was expecting a bloodbath for the first go. But to my surprise, it was one of the most pleasant shaves. Least effort to BBS. Used a DE89 and was careful. Alum did sting a little bit more, but nothing extra ordinary. So, is the reputation well earned?