Irisch Moos cream vs. soap

[Captain Flint]

Hello everyone
I'm a big Irisch Moos fan and I got converted to the cult after trying one of their tubes. Now I'd like to get a shaving stick for travel purposes and just can't decide between Tabac and IM. I just need to know one thing: is there a big difference between the scent of the two IM's (cream and soap stick)?
Please try to be as much objective as possible in your appreciation (I know it's kinda hard but I need a clear view here).
Thanks for your time.

Cheers,
Vasco R

 

[Austin]

I like the shave cream. I don't like the stick. I like subtle scents and the stick is not subtle at all. It smells like cheap perfume.

 

[Captain Flint]

I like the shave cream. I don't like the stick. I like subtle scents and the stick is not subtle at all. It smells like cheap perfume.

Thanks Austin.
I was fearing that. One example: I enjoy shaving with Palmolive cream but when I bought the shaving stick I was really disappointed. IMHO the differences are too strong for me to be able to even compare the two scents, and that despite some folks here in B&B saying they smell the same.
I will post this question in the soap forum and see the reactions from the soap-lovers.

 

[Dharion]

In my book it's vice versa: the Palmolive stick is much better than the cream. Can't comment on the Irisch Moos stick vs. cream coz I only got the stick. Anyway I don't like to travel with creams, sticks are easier to handle and manlier/heftier.