Instead of a replate why not just try to polish it. If you don't care that the top plate may look a little copper or the handle a little brass, polish it. I did this gold tech with my large buffing wheel and a die grinder with a polishing wheel attached. It's a cheap alternative to a replate and gives you something a little one off. I also have a hand held Dremel that I'm sure would work, its just that its much smaller and the pads are more expensive. At that point it may be more effective to have a replate done. If you've polished one up please share I'd like to see what others have done as well with their ugly ducklings.