Good recommendations. Trying not to repeat, T+S's Sicily is as close to pure lemon as you can get, and GFT's Lime Skinfood is one of the most soothing.
I use a homebrew A/S of WH, 4711, glycerin and jojoba oil.
The classic 4711 kills the WH stink, and doesn't last all that long, which to me is an advantage, as it doesn't then conflict with the frag of the day.
A precise blend of aloe vera and lemongrass oil, Blue Water Facial Spray offers a burst of fresh, revitalizing energy while working to heal and prevent razor bumps, abrasions, and other skin irritations that follow a close shave.
I recently received a soap from Black Ship Groomiong called Thomas Tew...it's a blend of different orange scents...smells great. They have it in an aftershave.