If you had to choose only one.

[herbert7890]

MDC Unscented

 

[lucabrassi]

wow, tough question

mine would be razorock don marco hard intense but unfortunately they dont make it anymore, so ill go with stirling orange chill

 

[Hendo6682]

Mike's Lime

 

[GuanYu]

As much as I love my fancy creams and soaps, I'd choose Arko! Always get a great lather. I can even shave with just rubbing it on my wet face w/o lathering it up with a brush. Cheap, lasta a long itme, and it smells clean.

Mikes and Stirling would come in a close second.

 

[lemisanthrope]

B&M Lime, Lavender & Cedarwood

 

[nwjs]

The humble Palmolive stick.

 

[benzology]

Sharp Dressed Man

 

[jcs266]

I own exactly one soap and it's all I use. It's all I ever care to use. It works and it's awesome... ARKO!

 

[speedwell]

Musgo Real hands down. High performing with a scent you never get tired of. I like Cella as well but much like German food (or tortillas for that matter), I can only handle so much.

 

[keithmax]

For performance I would go AOS tallow. Not the best scents but the best performance. If only it smelled like MdC Fougere.

 

[rodmonster]

Through the Fire Fine Craft Extinguish.

It is another great Maria Arman tallow soap. Raspberry scent with a menthol kick. Perfect.

Maria Arman for President.
She will Change the Face of America

 

[BSAGuy]

La Toja

 

[mc3533]

As of today, I would say B&M Seville. My favorite seems to change over time; guess I haven't found that "it" soap some have found.

 

[mtsheron]

Mitchells Wool Fat for sure! Great stuff & hard to beat at $15 a puck!

 

[fightingillini22]

Haslinger Schafmilch, all the best parts of MWF without all the fuss imho

 

[clk]

Tabac

 

[onethinline]

My first thought was B&M Seville, but my second thought was Tabac. And really I think it would have to be Tabac. But tough call!

 

[cvargo]

Stirling Barbershop.

But that is unrealistic so I will stick with a rotation of about 15 soaps and 15 creams.

 

[gwgrooms]

Tabac

 

[ghorn11]

Mwf