If you could only pick one forever...

[anoop]

Mdc vetyver

 

[CalmAsHinduCows]

Stirling’s Sheep - hands down, my #1 choice. It is pure shaving perfection for my skin.

 

[bluewater23t]

MdC Fougere or Cella, lol. What a spread.

 

[Wil_D]

MdC

 

[Beefdrippings]

Hmm. SV Desert Vetiver or maybe Tabac (new). Still wanting to try MdC from the jar and not samples.

 

[GR5233]

Hmm. SV Desert Vetiver or maybe Tabac (new). Still wanting to try MdC from the jar and not samples.

I’ve used both a sample size and full size version of the MdC original and from that experience I much prefer the full size version

To answer the question:
MdC (probably switching between original and fougere)
Pitralon classic (Germany)

 

[Balin]

Mitchell's Woolfat.

No contest! Nothing comes even close!

I have a brand new ceramic bowl of MWF that I bought in August and am planning on using it in December.

But even today the last day of Tabactober, I would have to go with Tabac!

 

[Ron R]

Soap: Speick stick (tallow) nice mild spicy scent with excellent lather qualities.
Splash: Razorock XXX, nice clean scent when it dries down.
Balm: CeraVe moisturizer lotion(scentless) Just works well.

 

[P-51G t]

Cella and Whiskey Woods
unsented vander hagen and Ogallala limes and peppercorn double strength
Sterling soap TBA and Pinaud Lime Sec

 

[P-51G t]

Cella and Whiskey Woods
unsented vander hagen and Ogallala limes and peppercorn double strength
Sterling soap TBA and Pinaud Lime Sec

I forgot to add that it would be 1 of these 3 sets

 

[JCarr]

Love these threads...they come along now and again.

Soap: PAA Atomic Age Bay Rum CK-6.
Splash: Barberry Coast Bay Rum aftershave splash.
Balm: No balms for me. However, I would use Lucky Tiger Face Tonic before the aftershave splash.

 

[Music]

Soap: AYLM Krokos
Splash: None
Balm: AYLM Krokos

 

[SP120K]

I could use Ghost Town Barber by Chiseled Face forever. Also I think Timmerman Red could be a forever soap too.

 

[DrStrange]

Stirling Deep Blue Sea shaving soap

Consul Plyn Po Goleniu after shave

 

[gpjoe]

MdC Fougere or Cella, lol. What a spread.

Those are quite different.

I use both but prefer MdC by a wide margin, though the Cella smells good enough to eat. In fact, I have been focusing on the Cella lately to make it my first tub to finish. Once it's gone, I don't think I will replace it.

 

[cf1]

Seville omnibus, clubman and unscented Zingariman balm.

PAA good vibrations and MWF close second.

 

[Watasha]

My main Summer aftershave is Aqua Velva & my main Winter aftershave is Clubman. That said, I agree with someone who earlier said if you're choosing only one thing forever you choose functionality. I'll go beyond that & say I would also choose products that aren't very strong scent-wise. I can use cologne for that if needed. So that said:

Soap: Arko (after I let it air out a bit)
Aftershave: Speick

Arko just does exactly what is supposed to do at a very affordable price. Speick is a mild, inoffensive scent that also performs amazingly well. It's my go to after the rare subpar shave when I actually NEED a good aftershave product.

 

[Keto]

I have several soaps but the A & E tubs actually get finished. Of those So Cal Hipster is fun to me.

 

[Pepin]

I will follow your example with my three sets.
Soap: Tabac
Splash: Tabac

Soap: Geo F. Trumper Eucris
Splash: Pinaud Clubman Classic/Orginal

Cream: Geo F. Trumper Spanish Leather
Splash: Geo F. Trumper Spanish Leather

 

[Markdad2]

Soap - Barrister & Mann Reserve Spice, Splash - Barrister & Mann Reserve Spice. Anything in the Omnibus Base would be good, but the Spice scent is such a classic I could wear it everyday and be AOK.