If you could only have one scent from the following soap makers what would it be?

[roosty]

1. Fine Accoutrements
2. Grooming Dept.
3. Declaration Grooming
4. Wholly Raw
5. B&M
6. Stirling

Thanks!

 

[GearNoir]

Sandalwood, that’s my scent kryptonite.

 

[gmdnk]

1. Grooming Dept - Neroli
2. Fine - Platinum
3. B&M - Seville

Not tried those other soaps, unfortunately.

 

[Newmania]

Fine American Blend
DG Bandwagon
B&M Cool

Stirling soaps don’t perform great for me but Island Man smells great.

I don’t love any of the scents I’ve come across from WK or GD but King of Oud and Kulfi are good enough to keep around for the fantastic performance.

 

[jdp93]

Fine - Platinum
Grooming Dept - Magnolia
Declaration- Darkfall
Wholly Kaw - Fougere Bouquet
B&M - Leviathan
Stirling - Iced Pineapple


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mceuph75]

of the ones I’ve tried:

1. Fine Santal Absolute
3. Declaration Grooming Trismegistus
5. B&M Reserve Spice
6. Stirling Piacenza

 

[Glaze3]

Fine - Fresh Vetiver
Grooming Dept. - Magnolia
Wholly Kaw- Foutere Bouquet
B&M- Reserve Cool
Declaration - Darkfall

 

[MacDaDad]

Barrister & Mann Leviathan

 

[Heron]

Fine - Fresh Vetiver
B&M - Fern
Stirling - Gin & Tonic

 

[chibi]

Declaration Grooming - Trismegistus
Wholly Kaw - La Fougere Parfaite
B&M - Le Grand Chypre or Rhapsody
Stirling - Vanilla Sandalwood or Barbershop

 

[Mullen88]

Grooming Dept - Conca d’Oro
Declaration Grooming - Rose Santal
Wholly Kaw - King of Oud
Barrister and Mann - 42
Stirling - Margaritas in the Arctic

 

[seattleshaver]

Stirling- Christmas Eve

 

[pbrmhl]

1. Fine Accoutrements: American Blend
2. Grooming Dept.: Mallard
3. Declaration Grooming: Blackberry Blossom Bay
4. Wholly Raw: King of Oud
5. B&M: Reserve Fern
6. Stirling: I've never tried one. It's on my list someday.

 

[Pedict]

1. Fine Accoutrements - Italian Citrus
2. Grooming Dept. - Magnolia and Oud
3. Declaration Grooming - After the Rain
4. Wholly Kaw - Chypre Rose Concerto
5. B&M - Reserve Classic
6. Stirling - Bay Rum

 

[jaxstraww]

1. Fine Accoutrements - Platinum
2. Grooming Dept. - N/A
3. Declaration Grooming - Gratiot League Square
4. Wholly Kaw - YRP
5. B&M - Reserve Spice
6. Stirling - Dirty South Shavers (Fierce)

Sent from my Samsung S8+

 

[DannyZ]

Fine - never tried
Grooming Dept - Chai
Declaration Grooming - Harmony
Wholly Kaw - Man from Mayfair
B&M - Cheshire
Stirling - Nag Champa

 

[Tokyospike]

Fine - Santal Absolut
Declaration - Gratiot League Square
B+M - Reserve Spice
Stirling - Weekend in Malibu

 

[imcnok]

From that list the only tub I finished was Cheshire from barrister

 

[BigJ]

Fine American Blend would be my choice from those options! (Classic barbershop IMO!)

 

[DEdestroyer77]

I've used all the artisans and many scents from most. I will not pick a scent clone of a fragrance since technically its not their scent

Fine - none
Grooming Dept - none
Declaration Grooming - After the Rain
Wholly Kaw - La Fougere Parfaite
B&M - Seville
Stirling - Nag Champa

If I was choosing clone or collaboration scents:
Fine - none
Grooming Department - none
Declaration Grooming - Trismegistus goes ahead of Bon Vivant by the slightest of margins
Wholky Kaw - La Fougere Parfaite
B&M - Reserve Cool
Stirling - probably Executive Man barely edging out Nag Champa.....barely