I want the Ogallala effect without the scent

[Steveareno]

Let me explain. I recently started using Ogallala Bay Rum with Sandalwood and absolutely love the way it smells. But what I love even more is the way my skin feels after applying it -- soft, smooth, and well-soothed. I would use it everyday for that reason alone. Some days I want to add some cologne before heading off to work, but if I use the Ogallala I can't, since it would potentially clash with the cologne.

What I'm wondering is whether there is an aftershave that can do what Ogallala does for my skin but without adding any scent. It doesn't have to be unscented necessarily, but if it is scented it needs to be something so subtle or short-lived that it wouldn't clash with a cologne applied say an hour after shaving.

Any suggestions would be most appreciated.

 

[brucea]

maybe a good witch hazel

 

[Steveareno]

I use witch hazel immediately following my shave, and it does a great job of soothing, but doesn't have that smoothing effect. After using Ogallala, my skin is dry but has a sort of "finish" to it that feels great to the touch. It's hard to describe, but different from what I get with any of the witch hazels I've used.

 

[njpaddy]

I know the feeling that you're talking about with Ogallala. I have all 4 of the Ogallala aftershaves and other than Captain's Choice Bay Rum, the rest of my aftershaves haven't been used for months. I rarely use cologne, except Ogallala cologne, so it's not an issue. I suppose if I was wanting to use a cologne, I'd probably just stick with the Dickinson's witch hazel and skip the Ogallala that day.

 

[fccexpert]

Look at the ingredients.

 

[strop]

Not sure about ingredients, but I get that feeling with the original Razorock aftershaves. I've only used the #888 and King Louis and can't comment on the newer offerings.

 

[TheVez2]

I'm not sure what is in it, but maybe you're wanting something with more glycerin in it?

 

[delamain]

I don't find that the Ogallala scent is very long lasting. I can't even smell the cologne after a few minutes. So, personally, I'd be able to use it along with a cologne that was at least somewhat compatible.

I just checked the ingredients list on my bottles and witch hazel is really the only thing present that would have a benefit - you can't add essential oils without adding a fragrance, so if they are supplying any skin benefits then you are out of luck.

I'd consider adding aloe and glycerine to some witch hazel, or something like that, just for the sake of experimentation. (Props to TheVez2 for saying it first)

 

[RobAtSGH]

Lucky Tiger Aftershave Tonic. Alcohol free, with aloe, witch hazel and chamomile. Very soothing and conditioning. Light citrus scent that dissipates quickly.

 

[brucea]

I use witch hazel immediately following my shave, and it does a great job of soothing, but doesn't have that smoothing effect. After using Ogallala, my skin is dry but has a sort of "finish" to it that feels great to the touch. It's hard to describe, but different from what I get with any of the witch hazels I've used.

I know what you mean I have the same result when using Ogallala. But the witch hazel is a close second for me.

 

[HogwildUSMC]

I was just thinking this the other day... The finish on Ogallala is something that I don't get from other aftershaves. I don't use it everyday but always like the days on when I do. I still have that tight smooth feeling hours later

 

[Steveareno]

Lucky Tiger Aftershave Tonic. Alcohol free, with aloe, witch hazel and chamomile. Very soothing and conditioning. Light citrus scent that dissipates quickly.

Yes, from what I've read, the Lucky Tiger scent is gone almost immediately, but it sounds like it might have a similar effect on the skin. I'll have to give it a try.

 

[P-51G t]

I get the same feeling with ogallala. And while lucky tiger feels very nice , ogallala has a different feel to it. I was wondering if anyone has nailed down this secret ingredient. Could it be the result of how the ingredients interact? Bueller bueller?

 

[Chaucer]

Thayers alcohol-free toner has WH and aloe. There's an unscented version, but
even the scented versions are very light. Nice but barely discernible after a few minutes.

 

[FireDragon76]

Lucky Tiger Aftershave Tonic. Alcohol free, with aloe, witch hazel and chamomile. Very soothing and conditioning. Light citrus scent that dissipates quickly.

I would recommend something like this over using drugstore witch hazels... which can be harsh and sensitizing. A blend of hydrosols and extracts is much better for your skin.

I know witch hazel is popular on the forum, but I save it for actual first aid. I may apply some witch hazel if I have some actual razor burn, but not as a general aftershave treatment.

I'd consider adding aloe and glycerine to some witch hazel, or something like that, just for the sake of experimentation. (Props to TheVez2 for saying it first)

I make homemade aftershave using rosewater, aloe juice, witch hazel, and glycerin, and it just has a vague green herbal scent that doesn't last long. But depending on what exactly you are using, you might need to add a preservative system that is broad spectrum. While the rosewater is basically self-preserving for a period of time, the aloe juice and witch hazel aren't, necessarily, and the preservatives they might contain (even alcohol) won't necessarily have an additive effect. Adding in high-proof alcohol to make a 20-25 percent solution will act as a preservative if you have nothing else, though it will be more harsh and drying.

FWIW, adventurous types have used rosewater alone as an aftershave, and it seems to work decently. You can also add a small amount of glycerin to the rosewater to make it more moisturizing. Because rosewater naturally is self-preserving, and the glycerin is a mildly bacteriostatic, it should last a fair amount of time if kept in a cool place away from sunlight. The only downside I suppose is that the scent of rosewater will linger for a while, though it isn't as strong as a real cologne would be.

 

[FireDragon76]

BTW, I just thought I'd plug Humphrey's toner as an aftershave

Amazon.com : humphreys toner

Their Cucumber Melon toner works well as aftershave, and I always keep some in the fridge to keep it cold (though it doesn't need cold, it just feels better that way). Though the scent lingers for about twenty minutes or so, I haven't found that to be a turnoff. If you wear an aquatic fragrance, it should blend in.

 

[Adis653]

I had started a journey about a year ago to find an unscented (or even lightly scented) splash that works for me after years of not using a splash. I used an old sample of captains choice bay rum and the feeling was amazing. I sadly have not found a great scentless solution after buying a bunch of samples and trying different things. I landed on thayers original astringent (the one with alcohol). I have had several iterations of the toner, but it lacked alcohol and I didn’t like the face feel it left me. Honesty it’s the best post shave feel I’ve gotten from any splash. The scent of the original however is gross and kicks my shave right between the legs. I just ordered the lemon astringent as well which I look forward to trying.

 

[geneaut]

I would recommend something like this over using drugstore witch hazels... which can be harsh and sensitizing. A blend of hydrosols and extracts is much better for your skin.

I know witch hazel is popular on the forum, but I save it for actual first aid. I may apply some witch hazel if I have some actual razor burn, but not as a general aftershave treatment.



I make homemade aftershave using rosewater, aloe juice, witch hazel, and glycerin, and it just has a vague green herbal scent that doesn't last long. But depending on what exactly you are using, you might need to add a preservative system that is broad spectrum. While the rosewater is basically self-preserving for a period of time, the aloe juice and witch hazel aren't, necessarily, and the preservatives they might contain (even alcohol) won't necessarily have an additive effect. Adding in high-proof alcohol to make a 20-25 percent solution will act as a preservative if you have nothing else, though it will be more harsh and drying.

FWIW, adventurous types have used rosewater alone as an aftershave, and it seems to work decently. You can also add a small amount of glycerin to the rosewater to make it more moisturizing. Because rosewater naturally is self-preserving, and the glycerin is a mildly bacteriostatic, it should last a fair amount of time if kept in a cool place away from sunlight. The only downside I suppose is that the scent of rosewater will linger for a while, though it isn't as strong as a real cologne would be.

I've used this before:
Mario Badescu Facial Spray with Aloe Herbs and Rosewater

 

[Xaltotun]

Which products have Ogallala? I feel like trying them now that I had a look at this thread!

 

[FaceScraper]

why not make your own?
1 part Thayers UNSCENTED alcohol free witch hazel
1 part Everclear (practically 100% alcohol)
Add a few drops of glycerin

ive done that a few times and liked the results. i usually add some essential oils for scent but since you want unscented just dont add any.

Thats it.