Speick Shave Cream, Speick Aftershave, and Tabac shaving soap
Well, you have to spend $35 for free shipping, so you may as well be looking at what you could get for that amount.
Speick after shave (dying to try this) and a tube or tub of Proraso red (dying to try this too!)
Ok, so the truth is I did have a $25 gift card to Amazon. Got it for Christmas and was itching to use it. I posed the hypothetical question to get some ideas. I've had a number of items on my wish list for sometime but what I ended up buy was:
Pinaud Clubman Vanilla
Speick aftershave lotion
Two Arko shave sticks
Everything with shipping came out over $25 so I paid the difference. All I had to pay out of pocket was about $9.