i divide my aftershaves (and creams) by summer and winter use.
Therefore for the summer I currently have -
TOBS Mr. Taylors
Adagio Aftershave Splash
Poraso Green
For winter -
Captain's Choice North
Captain's Choice Cat o' Nine Tails
Henri et Victoria Cognac and Cuban Cigar
Crown Tonic
Proraso Sandalwood
AS splash:
Old Spice Original, Musk, Leather, Burley. All vintage pre 1974.
Old Spice New Original blend from Rubicon
English Leather Musk vintage
Canoe vintage
Tabac Original
Fine Platinum
Brut 33 vintage
AS balms:
CH sport balm
Spicebomb balm
Dior Savauge balm
Dr. Carvers balm
Nivea sensitive balm
Narciso Rodriguez Him balm
Last , but certainly not least, Thayers Witch hazel medicated. More coming, stay tuned.......
I count 21, including 3 balms, excluding samples. Out of the 21, there are a handful that get the most day in, day out use - Skin Bracer, Nivea Sensitive Balm, Clubman Vanilla, Pinaud Citrus Musk, Lucky Tiger Face Tonic and Lucky Tiger Aspen.
I am planning to thin down the collection a bit in some upcoming PIFs, but I surprised myself with that count. On the other hand, after seeing some of the other responses, I don't feel like my collection that that excessive
Over 50. The old classics which are still wonderful after all these years. Also many of the outstanding Stirling products and St Charles Shave. I also love Lemomelon from the Shaving Soap Co. Very impressed with the newer Stirling line such as Arkadia and Dunshire. Fine also has a quality product line, American Blend my overall fav, and Stirling Orange Chill my #1. But I will state that I AM NOT, NOR I HAVE I EVER SUFFERED FROM AFTERSHAVE ADDICTION.
And I thought I had too many!
Looks like 11. Although I'm working through and using up the ones I can't get locally. I will then limit my rotation to both Aqua Velva scents, Pinaud Clubman, Mennen Skin Bracer or Barbasol Brisk. So I should be down to 4 sometime in 2020. I must say I love the Proraso Green Splash & RazoRock Puros and will be sorry to see them used up, but I get perfectly fine results with my future set rotation. Rarely use the RR Problem Solver as I haven't overdone it in a long while. Same goes for the Thayer's.
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Aqua Velva Musk
Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum
Mennen Skin Bracer
Barbasol Brisk
Proraso Green Splash
Proraso Green Balm
RazoRock Puros
RazoRock Problem Solver
Thayer's Witch Hazel w/Aloe
Fine fresh Vetiver
Fine platinum
Fine American blend
Fine snakebite (haven't used yet)
Fine clean Vetiver
Fine absolut santal
Proraso green ASL
TOBS sandalwood ASL
Balms:
ES balm
Proraso white ASB
Proraso Blue ASB
Nivea Sensitive ASB