I recently bought some TOBS Sandalwood cream off A***** for a cheaper than normal price, and believe it’s gone bad. It was darker around the rim than the center, and it smelled very “off”, not right at all. I can only imagine how long it sat in a warehouse or wherever, possibly too warm at that. The seller refunded me without even asking for the item back, so they probably know they are selling old stock and got it so cheap they can afford to lose a few. Creams definitely go bad though!