Bernd of Shavemac turned me on to Haslinger, the Marigold and Seaweed soaps and I can honestly say, on their own, the non tallow soaps perform very well. When I add them to Tabac and Stirling Sheep containers, both tallow, the Haslinger/Tallow combo makes for an excellent shaving soap. I liked this combo so much that I ordered additional Stirling Sheep pots and Haslinger’s aloe, milk and sandalwood pucks. Use what you feel most comfortable with, tallow or non tallow… what’s available in the marketplace is exceptional.