I think I could pull together something like this at some point.
That would be great!
You might wish to include this link:
http://www.tobaccoreviews.com/
Then, again, you might not. There are some curmudgeons and braggards on there, but it won't take the discerning gentleman long to learn who should just be ignored. There's a fabulous wealth of information there, if you can strain out the occasional olive pit in your martini.
-Andy