La Toja came to my mind as well
You may also want to look into those Mediterranean blus or blue barbershop type scents.
B&M cool
Furbo
Razorock Blue Barbershop
+1 (make that +2!) for La Toja!!
I get that too on the Mitchell’s. To me it just smells like a wonderful everyday soap.To me, MWF is the very definition of smells like soap. Some folks smell the lanolin or sheep smell. I get a bit of ashtray off La Toja, as do others, but it's mild and it works well so I deal with it. I get too much rosemary off PDP. My point being, everyone seems to interpret scent differently.
To *me*, MWF = soap. SV Felce = green and fresh. SV is a lot stronger too.