What's new

Feedback on A&E Which One’s Pink ASL

Anyone enjoying this A&E release? I recently picked this up and having a hard time reconciling the scent i smell with the notes copy. How about the face feel, cinnamon is usually a hot ingredient topic.

Notes: Pink pepper , pink grapefruit, tangerine, lavender, cinnamon, pink rose, myrrh, black currant, sandalwood, Haitian vetiver, amber, patchouli, musk and vanilla.

“Which One's Pink is a woody-oriental scent, leaving you comfortably numb with it's mysterious, alluring and sultry notes.

This sneaks right into your underpants and leaves you feeling slightly dirty...and smug about it. This is a smokey bar, a distant city, some dark red lipstick, and a cab back to your hotel in last nights clothes. It's bad news all the way to it's core...and there is no way to resist it. After a few hours, you'll catch a whiff still lingering and you'll remember last night's heathen mischief with that naughty, naughty girl...Like a Rock Star!

This may not have the smell of 'Money', but you will be richly rewarded with smokey sandalwood, cinnamon, cardamon and pink pepper. Further elevating your senses, light florals were added to round out some edges. The addition of tobacco, cardamom, vanilla, musk and amber make this filthy. “
 

Steve56

Ask me about shaving naked!
Sounds interesting Jon, I don’t do artisans much anymore, but your review tempts me.
 
Sounds interesting Jon, I don’t do artisans much anymore, but your review tempts me.

steve, none of that is my review, it's all the copy from A&E's site. I've used this AS 2x and like 2-3 drops each time, it's ridiculously strong to my nose and skin. It smells nice, a bit sweeter than I would have expected from the notes and I have to cut it with WH to make it a bit more mild.
 
just to follow up.. the strength was an issue for me ( I have tried one other A&E aftershave/soap (Paris?) and similar issues). almost unusable after a shave, wanted to wash it off due to the burn. i would add a teaspoon or 2 WH to my hand and then 2 or 3 drops of which ones pink.

So I decided to cut Which One's Pink ASL 50/50 (about 10ml) with some generic WH in a separate 1oz bottle and the strength issues are gone. much smoother and balanced scent and feel, my family and I don't feel overwhelmed with the scent, it's way more balanced not so cinnamon forward anymore, and the tingle is pretty much 99% less (now enjoyable versus pretty much unusable for me before).. i think i am going to order an unscented ASL and make some other mixtures.
 
Top Bottom