I find the longevity of WW to be about the same, but it is a very different type of scent. Clubman original is a very bright and loud scent if over applied but very classy if done right, especially after a round of golf. Whiskey Woods is a mellow pipe tobacco scent that makes me want to sit by the fireplace on a fall or winter day.
I received my WW order. You are correct on the WW profile. It is a very different ASL from Clubman and other popular ASL's. WW is a mellow smooth comfortable scent. The feeling when wearing WW is peaceful. I like WW and think that it will be a mainstay.