Dominica, Carribian, Capt Smith's

[bluefoxicy]

Worthwhile difference between Dominica and Caribbean? I think I am after Captain Smith's... Dominica seems very bright with sweet bay smell, not sure if Caribbean will actually smell different.

Anyone tried all three? This might be a gsixgun question...

 

[The Knize]

Worthwhile difference between Dominica and Caribbean? I think I am after Captain Smith's... Dominica seems very bright with sweet bay smell, not sure if Caribbean will actually smell different.

Anyone tried all three? This might be a gsixgun question...

I would love to know the answer. I have only tried Domenica, and it seems very pure bay tree leaf extract to me in a strong concentration--one of the purest.

I assume there are differences. I have never tried two BRs that were exactly the same, and additives such as clove, cinammon, real rum, and I am sure other things, are tradtional and thus acceptable, I would say, parts of some recipes for BR, even if folks like me tend to prefer a very pure bay tree leaf formula.

Superior 70 seems to be a very pure bay tree leaf solution to me in a lighter concentration, for instance, but I have not come across any other BRs that seemed as pure as Domenica and S 70, not that I my nose is all that good.

 

[BillC]

Both the Bonny Doon and St John's are also nice, clean bay rums without the spice.

 

[bluefoxicy]

I just splashed half-and-half Pinaud VI/Dominica on my arms.

I'm definitely wearing this tonight.