Late to this conversation!We should trust that Shane knows his products. The issue here, per my last post, is that the web product listing for this razor should communicate that this metal will quickly develop a patina instead of just noting a "mirror finish".
Given that this is a one-off batch of 70 razors using this bronze on an experimental basis and that Shane has quickly acknowledged and owned the issue I don't see this as something that has a major impact on the brand. Blackland should update its website copy to better communicate the characteristics of this material.
P.S. Edit, Given that this is a $330 razor Blackland may also want to reach out to anyone who has already ordered one on this issue.
I have one and luckily arrived pristine. And even with our hard water & humidity in Florida, it's still pristine after a month. This has actually surprised me since I know that shiny bronze tarnishes pretty quickly.
I've had that experience before with other polished bronze & brass razors! I've even had some that have arrived starting to patina.
It's a normal process with bronze and brass!
Grab some Flitz and a quick 5 minute polish takes care of the issue. So what I'm saying is that if my Bronze Blackbird would have arrived with some spots, I would have done a quick polish because I know this is normal (yes it can start to patina as soon as it leaves the shop!)
I'm guessing the OP hasn't had experience with polished bronze which is pretty quick to patina as I had already mentioned.
As for the customer service issue, the situation stinks but stuff happens and I think an explanation and resolution occurred 2 pages back. So Blackland messed it up but it seems like they made it up by explaining and positively reacting with a resolution.
Sounds like a good outcome to me!