Creed Original Vetiver

[shakin_jake]

Which versions are recommended, and why...what do you wear and when (when using Creed Original Vetiver)?

Kicking this one around...thinking of an impulse buy*...I see it is offered in more than just an EdT and wanted to get other's thoughts



Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

*luvs me some vetiver

 

[global_dev]

I enjoy the current version. Not exactly sure what you are asking. I don't wear anything specifically different with it in regards to clothing.

 

[gegarrenton]

I can never find the original, so have no reference.

 

[StylinLA]

Not quite sure I understand the questions either shakinjake. To my knowledge, there is only one version of a Creed Original Vetiver. It comes in different size bottles though. I believe it is considered an EdP.

The name of it confuses many people. The term "original" in the name of this scent is meant to mean it's a unique or "original" interpretation on vetiver. It does not mean it was the first vetiver Creed produced. Original Vetiver was launched in 2004.

Creed made another scent simply called "Vetiver" which is now discontinued. That one is usually referenced in frag forums as Vetiver 1948, the date when it was supposedly first issued. There is a tendency with many to confuse the two, not understanding the term Original is literally the name of the 2004 scent, not a reference to it being their first vetiver offering.

They are very different scents. Original Vetiver is fresh, green, soapy modern scent. Vetiver (1948) is gingery, mineralic, mature, Mad Men kind of scent.

I see you love vetiver, but you should sample first. Many vetiver enthusiasts are not fond of Original Vetiver. It is a different kind of a take on vetiver, and a lot fresher and less earthy than most vetiver scents. I like it a lot. A great warm weather scent.

Original Vetiver is very similar to Mugler Cologne which is much cheaper.

 

[shakin_jake]

Mugler like Creed OV?...I was reading some threads over on basenotes earlier today in regards to Amouage Interlude man and one of the respondents was urging the OP wanting to try Amouage Interlude, to sample Mugler first, to possibly save some coin, what with Mugler being less expensive, and similar to Amouage Interlude Man!

Yes!, I've read where Creed's Original Vetiver is light on vetiver and not the dominant note by quite a few where others say if you like vetiver, you'll be happy with Creed's formulation (OV). My 1st vetiver was L'Occitane's and as those that have sampled, worn, wear it, L'Occitane's version has far more woods going on (I just doused myself with this frage...one spray over the heart, a 1/2 spray on one wrist rubbing that wrist to the other)

Apologies for not being clearer...(my question) regarding variation...I was under the impression there is more than one version currently being offered. Version as in potency (EdC, EdT, EdP) and I was left with that impression for several reasons. 1) my research has been casual. 2) several outlets have this product priced very high vs. not so exorbiant. I'm trying to recall sellers/pricing...from memory, Bergdorf/Goodman wanted $300 + for 4 ounces, Fragrancedot net or maybe it was scentiments was $162...(4 ounces), which led me to believe there are several versions...none of the verbiage (product info) from what I recall seemed clear as to the potency, strength

I like buying frags blind, I also order teaser bottles on occasion (2ml, 4ml). I've yet to buy a frag I simply wont wear. Some get more use. thank you for everyones input thus far, and feel free to add to this conversation



Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[YoungerThanMyRazor]

Mugler and Creed OV are very similar in my opinion. Creed OV is just slightly smoother and more rounded. I think if you like one, you will like the other, and you don't need both.

 

[tehtimmeh]

Creed OV is my hot weather go to. Great stuff! I echo others comments that it is very different from Creed's "classic" grey cap vetiver which is also good in it's own right. OV is similar to Mugler cologne, but much less synthetic.

As far as versions go, there is only one version of Creed OV and it is a "millesime" which is supposed to be EdP strength. If you are looking for a vetiver scent, this isn't it. The vetiver is there, but it's more of a fresh, clean, soapy frag. The vetiver holds it all together.

 

[shakin_jake]

Mugler like Creed OV?...I was reading some threads over on basenotes earlier today in regards to Amouage Interlude man and one of the respondents was urging the OP wanting to try Amouage Interlude, to sample Mugler first, to possibly save some coin, what with Mugler being less expensive, and similar to Amouage Interlude Man!

~~~Apologies to StylinLA...I went back through the threads (in history) I read and realized I was also reading a few Creed OV threads (OnIn BN) where other posters said to try Mugler. I did not read this in the Amouage threads (Mea Culpa)



Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[Cuttingboard]

Is this the Mugler your talking about?

 

[StylinLA]

Is this the Mugler your talking about?

View attachment 293681

Yup. They are quite, quite similar.

shakinJake, got it. Indeed the fact that varying bottle sizes of Creed OV are seen all over at different prices can create confusion. They are all the same scent. Creed seems to have two distribution networks- though I don't think that's their idea.

There is their boutiques, and all the high end retailers like Nieman, Saks, Bergdorf, etc. the official distribution network.

But then there is a whole "undergound" network of many online retailers. Some of them are selling gray market Creed intended for distribution in the Middle East. Somehow Walgreens got hold of some Creed scents and sell them online only (or at least have in recent past). Here in LA, I often run I to Creed at mom and pop type perfume shops as well. soometimes discounted; sometimes not.

Enough of us have purchased Creeds through some of discounted websites to know its generally authentic; not fake knockoffs.
But there are endless and raging discussions about whether some of the scents are old, not fresh enough etc. creed in particular is subject to many of these "I got a bad bottle" discussions.

 

[shakin_jake]

Yup. They are quite, quite similar.

shakinJake, got it. Indeed the fact that varying bottle sizes of Creed OV are seen all over at different prices can create confusion. They are all the same scent. Creed seems to have two distribution networks- though I don't think that's their idea.

There is their boutiques, and all the high end retailers like Nieman, Saks, Bergdorf, etc. the official distribution network.

But then there is a whole "undergound" network of many online retailers. Some of them are selling gray market Creed intended for distribution in the Middle East. Somehow Walgreens got hold of some Creed scents and sell them online only (or at least have in recent past). Here in LA, I often run I to Creed at mom and pop type perfume shops as well. soometimes discounted; sometimes not.

Enough of us have purchased Creeds through some of discounted websites to know its generally authentic; not fake knockoffs.
But there are endless and raging discussions about whether some of the scents are old, not fresh enough etc. creed in particular is subject to many of these "I got a bad bottle" discussions.

~~~fingers crossed that a fresh bottle will be sent my way...I pulled the trigger on a 4 ounce bottle around 3 AM this morning, buying from fragrance.net. Couldn't resist,they were offering 20% off/free ship...I'm a sucker for a good sale
$129/change OTD

Although I don't have to legitimize why I bought this bottle to all of you frag hounds here, after reading many reveiws over on basenotes, especially shamu1's...I have an idea this will be to my liking. I've found scent reviews he's written for scents I have/use to be in align with my experience. Maybe our body chemistry is similar. I know when it comes to trying new green coffees, I use a similar stradegy buying green beans to roast. There are more than a few distributors at the club I buy most of my greens from and one in particular sources greens I've always enjoyed whereas it took me a few purchases to find another distributor's greens were usually a tad too bright (overall) for my likes

I realize Creed Vetiver will not have a dominant vetiver scent. I can live with that, and look forward to appreciating it's grassy vetiver appeal so many write about, at least those that note vetiver at all. Some seem to miss the vetiver note entirely. I mentioned earlier this would be an impulse buy yet I have thought about trying it for awhile, having read reviews of it in the past. It's an impulse buy in that I was not planning on dropping the jack to pay for it this week It should get here next week...I'll post some thoughts after I try it here in this thread



Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[erickson]

~~~fingers crossed that a fresh bottle will be sent my way...I pulled the trigger on a 4 ounce bottle around 3 AM this morning, buying from fragrance.net. Couldn't resist,they were offering 20% off/free ship...I'm a sucker for a good sale
$129/change OTD

Wish I'd piped in early and informed you about Walgreens sales. I picked up two 4oz bottles of Creed for under $200 during Walgreens After Christmas BOGO Sale last January. I got 4oz Creed Original Vetiver along with 4oz Creed Green Irish Tweed and they were both fresh juice bottled in 2011.

Anyway, I think you will like Original Vetiver. I did not care for Mugler Cologne primarily because it turns powdery and feminine on me after a few hours. Enjoy!

 

[Cuttingboard]

Wish I'd piped in early and informed you about Walgreens sales. I picked up two 4oz bottles of Creed for under $200 during Walgreens After Christmas BOGO Sale last January. I got 4oz Creed Original Vetiver along with 4oz Creed Green Irish Tweed and they were both fresh juice bottled in 2011.

How did you know the bottle date? Is it like the born on date that have for beer?

 

[global_dev]

http://www.basenotes.net/threads/270780-Creed-lot-numbers...SOLVED

 

[The Knize]

Not quite sure I understand the questions either shakinjake. To my knowledge, there is only one version of a Creed Original Vetiver. It comes in different size bottles though. I believe it is considered an EdP.

The name of it confuses many people. The term "original" in the name of this scent is meant to mean it's a unique or "original" interpretation on vetiver. It does not mean it was the first vetiver Creed produced. Original Vetiver was launched in 2004.

Creed made another scent simply called "Vetiver" which is now discontinued. That one is usually referenced in frag forums as Vetiver 1948, the date when it was supposedly first issued. There is a tendency with many to confuse the two, not understanding the term Original is literally the name of the 2004 scent, not a reference to it being their first vetiver offering.

They are very different scents. Original Vetiver is fresh, green, soapy modern scent. Vetiver (1948) is gingery, mineralic, mature, Mad Men kind of scent.

I see you love vetiver, but you should sample first. Many vetiver enthusiasts are not fond of Original Vetiver. It is a different kind of a take on vetiver, and a lot fresher and less earthy than most vetiver scents. I like it a lot. A great warm weather scent.

Original Vetiver is very similar to Mugler Cologne which is much cheaper.

Excellent notes!

You will let us know when you find the discountinued Creed Vetiver 1948 (or the discontinued Cuir de Russie, Tabarome, Bois de Santal) at one of those mom and pop stores won't you? <g>

I do not much like either Creed Vetiver, but many sure do like the 1948 version. Not like may overstate it. Neither seems very vetiver to me. I sure get the Mad Man vibe to the 1948 version.

 

[mhdena]

Original Vetiver has become one of my favorites, I finished off a 2.5oz bottle recently and had a replacement on deck the same day.

 

[jakespoppy]

To me, Creed Original Vetiver has some similarity to Monsieur de Givenchy. Clean, fresh scents. I think you'll like it, Jake.

 

[buckeye_pi]

Yup. They are quite, quite similar.

shakinJake, got it. Indeed the fact that varying bottle sizes of Creed OV are seen all over at different prices can create confusion. They are all the same scent. Creed seems to have two distribution networks- though I don't think that's their idea.

There is their boutiques, and all the high end retailers like Nieman, Saks, Bergdorf, etc. the official distribution network.

But then there is a whole "undergound" network of many online retailers. Some of them are selling gray market Creed intended for distribution in the Middle East. Somehow Walgreens got hold of some Creed scents and sell them online only (or at least have in recent past). Here in LA, I often run I to Creed at mom and pop type perfume shops as well. soometimes discounted; sometimes not.

Enough of us have purchased Creeds through some of discounted websites to know its generally authentic; not fake knockoffs.
But there are endless and raging discussions about whether some of the scents are old, not fresh enough etc. creed in particular is subject to many of these "I got a bad bottle" discussions.

From what I've read (I wish I could find that article) Creed takes back unsold bottles from their prime distribution network (Saks et al) after a certain period of time and replaces them with new stock. The stock that they've taken back then winds up with their Internet retailers (FrangranceX and others) so you are buying older stock at discounted prices from the secondary distributors. I haven't read anything about the gray marker product destined for other countries.

 

[shakin_jake]

From what I've read (I wish I could find that article)

~~~if you read it on the internet, it must be true

Creed takes back unsold bottles from their prime distribution network (Saks et al) after a certain period of time and replaces them with new stock. The stock that they've taken back then winds up with their Internet retailers (FrangranceX and others) so you are buying older stock at discounted prices from the secondary distributors. I haven't read anything about the gray marker product destined for other countries.

~~~I distinctly remember one of my professors (Wayne State University, during the 80's) asking, "How do we know what we know?"






Best,


Jake
Reddick Fla.

 

[robochoche]

Do creed bottles spray very fine? I just bought my first bottle and it seems like the spray is very fine? Is that normal?