I just scored 3 tubes of proraso red at a marshalls store for $4.99 a piece. Great lather and one of my favorites along with the green. Along with red I have the green, old spice musk and a tube of Mem that I got from a fellow member.
I've got many, but my favorites are Wm Neumann (#1 in my book), XPEC, Castle Forbes, Meissner Tremonia, Baume.be, Esbjerg and, did I mention Wm Neumann? I'm looking forward to trying @GlazedBoker's Stone Cottage cream pass-around, as I've not tried a new cream for a very long time.