Osage rub is definately cooling, and once the menthol fumes die down a bit, the fragrence added is barely perceptable. It has alcohol, but less sting than many. Just be forewarned, its very addictive. Best choice I can thing of if you are going to follow up with a cologne.
I've kind of been on hold waiting to snag a bottle of Italian Floid. Hopefully, when it comes available I'll be able to find someone to split a bottle. The Spanish "Vigarosa" version is also well-regarded.
Very light, unobtrusive scent, with "By the Gods!" cooling. And cheap, like Austin said. I'm going to have to get some Osage Rub, see how much colder it is. If it's much cooler that Blue Line, I'll have to sell it.