What's new

Comparison of Weber and Ikon Bulldog handles

I recently picked up two R41's off the BST, one had a Weber Bulldog handle, the other an Ikon Bulldog handle. No real reason why I picked up two of the same razor without ever using it, but justified it by telling myself that I would end up selling the one with the handle I liked the least. :001_unsur

These handles for all intent purposes are essentially identical as far as dimensions and weight. They are the exact same length, and weigh pretty much the same, with only a 1 gram difference between the two (Weber: 70g, Ikon: 69g). There are only two major differences that I can find that exist between these handles. The first is the knurling. The weber has a deeper, coarser knurling, and as a result has a 'sharper' grip in the hand. The Ikon's knurling is a bit more polished and refined looking, and feels a touch more slick in my hand compared to the Weber. The other main difference is the price, with the Weber Bulldog costing $38 USD, and the Ikon clocking in at $48 USD.

So which one is better? Well, that's obviously up to the individual, but for me I prefer the Weber. I like the feel of the deeper knurling which provides a much better purchase compared to the ever slightly 'slippery' feel of the Ikon. I put 'slippery' in quotes because it really isn't slippery, but does not provide as sure of a grip as the Weber, and with a razor with the reputation of the R41, I don't want to take any chances! The Ikon has a slightly better finish, but again, taking the feel and grip of the handle into consideration, along with the cost of each, I prefer the Weber.

proxy.php


proxy.php


proxy.php


proxy.php


proxy.php
 
Great pictures! Thanks for sharing. Any trouble with loose threads with either handle with while tightening?
 
Last edited:
Great pictures! Thanks for sharing. Any trouble with loose threads with either handle with tightening?

Not at all. Both are spot on, with no issues with threads or tightening, and both stay tight.
 
I don't think first generation Bulldogs are available anymore from iKon..now they sell the Bulldog II which is 75g and 85mm long. So it is slightly longer and heavier than the Weber now, not enough to make much difference, it's basically a pissing contest on iKon's end IMO. They also had them on sale for $38 today for cyber Monday but I think that's over now.
 
I had an R41 which I put a Weber Bulldog handle on. I decided I liked it so much I ordered another R41 for my 2nd shave den at my girlfriends house. I also just ordered another Weber handle for it. Now I'll have identical razors for both dens.
 
I've been using an R41 with Weber Bulldog, too. But that handle is shared by other razor heads. I decided to order a GS1 handle for the R41.... I'm hopeful for its awesomeness! I was looking at the larger iKon too, but finally just liked the industrial look and price of the GS1. Weber handle is great, I just wanted variety to compare.
 
R41 stock handle is supremely light and a little on the slippery side. I like that it's slightly fat. But night and day on the original vs. the aftermarket handles in terms of both weight and grip.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the post. I've got the Ikon, and I really like it. However had I seen this before getting the Ikon I would have sent for the Webber and saved the $10 bucks. But what's done is done, and I do like the Ikon.
 
You got the bigger iKon with the deeper knurling I bet, yes? Maybe worth the 10extra bucks. I'd like to see a comparison of those.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom