I have new formula lime and love the scent. It's not a realistic lime, but smells nice and sweet imo it's better than lime musk aftershave's scent. Performance wise it's fairly good absolutely worth the $3 something I paid for it, it's pretty slick and for me using a synthetic(haven't tried natural with it yet) I have no complaints on lather. I don't really associate tallow with performance anymore, there are too many good soaps that are not tallow and some tallow soaps that aren't that good.