Congrats [MENTION=107672]brianjc[/MENTION] ... don't stay up nights thinking of the rest of us drinking Folger's
[MENTION=92373]TexLaw[/MENTION] ... great PIF after all, a man can only have so many soaps and creams ... and without coffee, we wouldn't be awake to shave.
Time for a review of the Brazil Carmo de Minas in the Full City dark roast....
First of all, thanks for this most generous PIF!
We grinded the beans to a medium ground and then brewed it in a French Press for about 5 minutes. The coffee had a strong bloom indicating freshness. The aroma was very strong.
I would agree with the description that this coffee has a smoothness of it that is missing in a lot of other dark roasts. There was a hint of toastiness at the end, but nothing like the bitterness that you would associate with over-roasted Starbucks coffees. This is a quality product.
My wife and I both strongly prefer dark roasts and french roasts. Our ideal is a very dark roast that only has a hint of bitterness. Typically, we prefer our coffees to be a darker roast than this. In fact, had this been a blind tasting, we would have assumed that this is a medium roast. We are going to experiment with different brewing times and grounding methods to see if we can coax a touch of bitterness and "roastiness" out of it. For those who like smooth medium roasts, this is worth trying. This is ideal for those who like medium-dark roasts.
If our impressions change as we experiment with different brewing techniques, I'll update the review. It usually takes a few brews to "dial in" the coffee to our preferences.
I prefer 6-7 days off the roast, might be why you are getting that "toasty" finish. Most roasters say 3, my taste buds say otherwise. The expansive bloom most likely with outgassing, just a guess, would tell me that you are only a few days off the roast. Congratulations on the PIF and thanks for the review.