So I've been using Clubman for the last few months now because it's the only decent aftershave I can find locally (aside from the Walmart fare of course). The upside to Clubman is that I LOVE the way it makes my skin feel, not tacky or greasy or shiny, with just the right amount of burn. The problem is that while the fragrance isn't horrible, I feel like there are aftershaves out there that I would like better. I have tried Masters Bay Rum aftershave and loved the smell of that, but it made my skin feel kind of tacky. So my question to you guys out there: What do you use that makes your skin feel similar to Clubman but doesn't have the Clubman scent?
Clubman: Love the Feel, Not so Much the Smell
- Thread starter Pipe Novelist
- Start date
If you like everything about classic Clubman but not the scent you may want to consider the other offerings in the Clubman lineup.
+1 on testing other lotions in the Clubman lineup. If you like the smell of Bay Rum why not try Pinaud's Virgin Island Bay Rum?
Try Clubman Bay Rum.
I'm with you on the feel/scent of Clubman Original. The Classic Vanilla is the way to go, even if you don't like vanilla the scent is gone within 30 minutes but the feel is the same as the original.
I really loved the smell of Clubman for about half a bottle, but I don't reach for it much anymore. It's just a little too sweet, I like Old Spice better.
Take it back! Clubman is the best scent on earth, basically.
I love Clubman, and my other favorite is Skin Bracer for a different scent. But Skin Bracer does have a "cooling" ingredient so you may not want that.
^^This^^. I wear the Vanilla almost everyday. When I don't, it's Clubman Bay Rum.
Clubman has always been my favorite scent. However, the Old Spice Monday thing has gotten me into OS now. Clubman is still my favorite, though.
I can never get enough of the Clubman scent! I think it's what heaven smells like.
I will say the Veg does leave my hands and face a little tacky afterwards so maybe you won't like it, ONLY for that reason
Clubman Vanilla has a pleasant scent that you may enjoy more.
I will say the Veg does leave my hands and face a little tacky afterwards so maybe you won't like it, ONLY for that reason
Clubman Vanilla has a pleasant scent that you may enjoy more.
- The Veg!
- Clubman Musk may be a good possibility. (Haven't tried it myself, but it's on my list.)
- How about Aqua Velva Ice Blue and/or AV Musk? They're widely available, and the scent is classic.
- If you're willing to go down a less-beaten path, consider Denim, Denim Musk, or one of the other varieties of Denim. You'll probably have to order online as I've only heard of it being available in shops in the UK. Denim Original and Musk are two of my favorite aftershaves. Good values, too.
Similar threads
