I'm leery of Clubman. I tried some of dad's Clubman Reserve Virgin Island Bay Rum. It smelled alright in three botttle but they was an rather unpleasant pair when it was in my face.
I've never tried their Bay Rum for the very reason that it has a reputation for having quite a burn. The others do not have that affect. I think it's Bay Rums in general that burn and not a particular brand.