Tabac.
Best performing soap?
- Thread starter flatlinerz
- Start date
Great list!! Especially because it includes many of my favorites!! 
MdC or SV.
It's an interesting question, but it could have been labeled "your favorite soap" and you would probably get the same answers. The responses are, by necessity, based on which soaps have been tried and personal preference. If I've tried only two soaps and liked one better than the other what is my answer worth?
It's an interesting question, but it could have been labeled "your favorite soap" and you would probably get the same answers. The responses are, by necessity, based on which soaps have been tried and personal preference. If I've tried only two soaps and liked one better than the other what is my answer worth?
Declaration Grooming Milksteak
Murphy and McNeil Kodiak
Murphy and McNeil Aon
Noble Otter
Cold River Soap Works Glide
Murphy and McNeil Kodiak
Murphy and McNeil Aon
Noble Otter
Cold River Soap Works Glide
Love it or hate for the scent, TABAC. (I love it)
Saponificio varesino is awesome.
La Toja
Ariana and Evans if you are looking for a artisan soap. (My stash is heaviest in this brand) there are a few fragrances that are hard to get but worth the wait.
MDC is good not great, just very easy to lather and long lasting in the tub.
PAA Isn’t bad soap, not convinced the ck-6 is worth the premium, and the marketing is too much, I just don’t know what to expect from most of the scents outside of the bay rum and cavendish lines. But when I use these soaps I am generally happy with the shave. The ck-6 base doesn’t last long, even with synthetic brushes you will burn through it quickly.
Saponificio varesino is awesome.
La Toja
Ariana and Evans if you are looking for a artisan soap. (My stash is heaviest in this brand) there are a few fragrances that are hard to get but worth the wait.
MDC is good not great, just very easy to lather and long lasting in the tub.
PAA Isn’t bad soap, not convinced the ck-6 is worth the premium, and the marketing is too much, I just don’t know what to expect from most of the scents outside of the bay rum and cavendish lines. But when I use these soaps I am generally happy with the shave. The ck-6 base doesn’t last long, even with synthetic brushes you will burn through it quickly.
Mike's Natural
Tabac
PAA CK6
A&E Kaizen
Mystic Waters
La Toja
Barrister and Mann
Tabac
PAA CK6
A&E Kaizen
Mystic Waters
La Toja
Barrister and Mann
Tabac.
These are pretty much the only ones that I’d buy again. Plenty of variety there so not looking for anything else anymore. If I had to pick one it would be AdP.
Acqua di Parma
Baume BE
Castle Forbes 1445
Nuavia Blu
Santa Maria Novella
Saponificio Varesino Cubebe 4.3
Speick
Tabac
Acqua di Parma
Baume BE
Castle Forbes 1445
Nuavia Blu
Santa Maria Novella
Saponificio Varesino Cubebe 4.3
Speick
Tabac
rbscebu
Girls call me Makaluod
I'm a face lathering SR shaver. For me so far, the best soap is Arko. My first Tabac should arrive within about a week. That may change things.
Lefonque
Even more clueless than you
I like and use many of the soaps listed, great recommendations. I enjoy both puck and stick. Currently enjoying Wilkinson Sword shave stick, which seems to fly under the radar. It’s a user friendly product and reasonably priced.
Grooming Dept
One of the creams on my wishlist
jackgoldman123
Boring and predictable
you will like it, i do
Many good soaps mentioned: Canada Shave Soap has yet to disappoint.
Arko
Cella
Speick
DR Harris
Tabac (tallow version)
Mitchells Wool Fat
Czech & Speake
Cella
Speick
DR Harris
Tabac (tallow version)
Mitchells Wool Fat
Czech & Speake
jackgoldman123
Boring and predictable
CRSW Glide
Zingari
SMN
Speick
Weleda
Boellis Panama
Zingari
SMN
Speick
Weleda
Boellis Panama
No money and a stuffy nose give arko a go.
A great classic give tabac a go.
Value for money and lots of choice order a sample pack of stirling and make sure part of that pack is mutton based. And there is more much much more.
A great classic give tabac a go.
Value for money and lots of choice order a sample pack of stirling and make sure part of that pack is mutton based. And there is more much much more.
SMN v3
AdP v3
Floris (current formula)
TAOS (tallow)
C&S (tallow)
Tabac (tallow, and maybe non-tallow)
AdP v3
Floris (current formula)
TAOS (tallow)
C&S (tallow)
Tabac (tallow, and maybe non-tallow)
Similar threads
