Best fragrance for a manly man?

[emwolf]

The EDTs that I like for the ego boost that a masculine scent gives me (right now)
Caswell Massey Number 6
Creed Green Irish Tweed
Guerlain Heritage
Terre de Hermes
Chiseled Face Ghost Town Barber

 

[tthoms]

Gun oil. I think it smells great.

After that...a manly man will wear whatever he wants. Who's going to tell him otherwise?
I like to wear British Sterling around work, Brut or English Leather when I'm out, something Liliac at church, and Fahrenheit when I feel the need to grow a third testicle.

 

[FarmerTan]

Gun oil. I think it smells great.

After that...a manly man will wear whatever he wants. Who's going to tell him otherwise?
I like to wear British Sterling around work, Brut or English Leather when I'm out, something Liliac at church, and Fahrenheit when I feel the need to grow a third testicle.

I'm familiar with all of them but the Fahrenheit. And since I like all of those, I'd probably like the Fahrenheit.

And what manly man couldn't use a third "tentacle" once in awhile?

 

[Cedarwood77]

Pinaud Clubman Special Reserve gets my vote

Yea, me too. Same goes for whisky woods. Problem is my girlfriend absolutely hates anything Clubman.

 

[FarmerTan]

Yea, me too. Same goes for whisky woods. Problem is my girlfriend absolutely hates anything Clubman.

It's weird. The only Pinaud's I use is Clubman, but my wife completely dislikes it. But she loves the smell of Arko. Go figger.

 

[tankerjohn]

Yea, me too. Same goes for whisky woods. Problem is my girlfriend absolutely hates anything Clubman.

I can see how that would be a problem. The solution is that you wear your SR when you're not around her. And when you are, wear something she likes. If you're still figuring that out, may I suggest Captain's Choice Sandalwood - it does the manly warm and woodsy thing similar to SR, but much more subtle and close wearing.

 

[tankerjohn]

Yea, me too. Same goes for whisky woods. Problem is my girlfriend absolutely hates anything Clubman.

I can see how that would be a problem. The solution is that you wear your SR when you're not around her. And when you are, wear something she likes. If you're still figuring that out, may I suggest Captain's Choice Sandalwood - it does the manly warm and woodsy thing similar to SR, but much more subtle and close wearing.

 

[Cedarwood77]

I can see how that would be a problem. The solution is that you wear your SR when you're not around her. And when you are, wear something she likes. If you're still figuring that out, may I suggest Captain's Choice Sandalwood - it does the manly warm and woodsy thing similar to SR, but much more subtle and close wearing.

Thank you kindly for the suggestion. I am indeed still figuring this out. You see If she ever actually did complement a scent on me I would probably pass out from shock. The best I have done lately was to have her smell a bit of Vetiver essential oil I rubbed onto my wrist. The praise was high! She said "Smells better then the other cheap crap you like"

 

[Nessunego]

I like sandalwood and spanish leather.

 

[Cedarwood77]

I second gun oil. Gun oil or Quorum. English leather as well but every one knows that.

 

[solseven]

Acqua Di Gio Pour Homme

 

[Champion of Capua]

 

[Bboon3]

B-M Beaudelaire EdT sounds right up your alley.

I love the B-M Beaudelaire aftershave splash but the EdT has been on backorder for some time. Are there other colognes that would make as a substitute or pair well the aftershave?

 

[global_dev]

I love the B-M Beaudelaire aftershave splash but the EdT has been on backorder for some time. Are there other colognes that would make as a substitute or pair well the aftershave?

#15 this might help. "Beaudelaire is a pretty unique scent. Brut comes close, but they are distinctly different to my nose. Perhaps a mix of Brut and English Leather, Beaudelaire has that sharp note that EL and Ayramis are known for." and a shout to Tuscany pour uomo