I'm with you, @BigJ - the old tallow version is awesome. I've still got about 150g in the Den .Had an absolutely terrific lather this AM with Haslinger’s schafmilch (the old ‘tallow’)!!
So far among the soaps I have tried...
1. Wholly kaw siero base
2. Declaration grooming milsteak base
3. Ariana & Evan's kaizen base
4. Martin de candre
5. Barrister & mann excelsior base
6. Extro cosmesi
7. Pannacrema Nuavia
8. Cella
9. TOBS sandalwood
I mean those with the most richest lather, with the best "after" the shave feeling