Bay Rum recommendation

Discussion in 'Aftershaves' started by Black-Tie, Mar 17, 2019.

    Hello gents,

    I’m looking for a bay rum aftershave splash with notes of cinnamon, cloves, citrus. Similar to Barberry Coast Bay Rum.
    Any suggestions?

    Thank you!

    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
  1. Clubman Bayrum is pretty good
  2. Captain’s Choice is my go to for anything Bay Rum. I’m especially fond of Cat O’ Nine Tails.
  3. I like Master Bay Rum but I know some guys don't like the glycerin content of it. I've heard that Gabels makes a nice Bay Rum but I haven't tried it yet.
  4. Gables Bay Rum is my go to.
  5. Krampert's Finest Bay Rum
  6. I think PAA Atomic age, Stirling, Chisled Face, and Ogallala Bay Rums are what you may be looking to try.
  7. Bootlegger’s Bay Rum. Equal parts VIBR, Master, and Superior 70.
  8. CO9T is a great fragrance!
  9. Bhugo

    Bhugo Contributor

    Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum is exactly what you ask for and affordable too. The rest of the recommendations are wonderful as well.
  10. I’m a big bay rum guy myself, I have however only used the Clubman and man I’m glad I did! My next Clubman will be a Phoenix artisan variant I’m sure.
  11. REV579

    REV579 Contributor

    I was wowed by CC’s Bay Rum. Give it a swirl!
  12. You should try out Meißner Tremonia Bay Rum.
    That is some crazy strong stuff. And a little unlike any Bay you smelled before.

    Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
  13. +1
  14. Captain’s Choice and PAA Atomic age
  15. Interesting! In what way does it set itself apart?
  16. Markante, aromatisch-würzige Note von naturreinem Bayöl (St. Thomas), abgerundet mit etwas Litsea und Nelkenblättern. Jamaica-Rum, Reines Schwarzwald-Quellwasser, Weingeist statt chemisch vergälltem Alcohol (Alcohol denat.), Extrakte von Bio-Hamamelis und Bio-Eukalyptus aus eigener Herstellung als Wohltat für die Haut.

    Inhaltsstoffe: Reines Quellwasser aus dem Schwarzwald, Bio Glycerin pflanzl., Bio Babassuöl, Bio Jojobaöl, Naturreines äth. Litsea Cubebaöl, Bio Kokosöl, braune Tonerde, Kaliumhydroxid, Kaolin, Macadamianussöl kaltgepresst, Natriumhydroxid, Naturreines äth. Bayöl, Naturreines äth. Nelkenblätteröl, Stearinsäure, Talkum, Totes Meer Kristallsalz, Zitronensäure

    That is the soap. Can’t find the AS, but it’s really nourishing, doesn’t feel weird on your face, all organic and the smell lasts forever! Really nice!
  17. I seem to be in the minority in not being a fan of the Captain's Bay Rum. I haven't tried the AS so perhaps it's different, but the soap sample I being smacked in the face with a ball of cloves. Not for me.

    I wish CRSW made a Bay Rum AS, because their soap is my favorite Bay Rum that I've tried.
  18. My favorite Bay Rum's in order:
    Bootlegger's Bay Rum
    Royall Bay Rhum

Share This Page